5 Fixes to Copyright

A competitive EU economy requires access to high-quality knowledge resources, legal certainty for those who use them, and sustainable institutions to maintain them. But there are challenges.

Here’s how to fix them.

Research in a cage

What’s the problem?

Researchers are not allowed to do data sharing.

The DSM Directive allows researchers doing text and data mining to make copies of research resources, but does not allow them to share research data and datasets. This hinders research transparency, collaborations and public-interest AI development in the EU.

What’s the fix?

Paywalled research

What’s the problem?

Publishers often do not allow researchers to publish in open access.

The prevailing scholarly publishing model frequently requires researchers to transfer their economic rights to publishers, preventing them from making their own publications openly available and restricting access to research that has already been financed by public funds.

What’s the fix?

Unfair contracts

What’s the problem?

Publishers often impose unfair licenses with choice-of-law clauses that undermine EU law.

Knowledge institutions face contractual restrictions on lawful uses, disproportionate liability for the conduct of users, arbitrary withdrawal of access to licensed resources, and restrictions on information-sharing.

What’s the fix?

Fear of liability

What’s the problem?

Legal uncertainty has a chilling effect on research.

EU knowledge institutions adopt risk-adverse approaches in response to legal uncertainty and perceived copyright risks, often choosing not to rely on EU exceptions despite strong arguments that their activities are lawful.

What’s the fix?

Long-term sustainability

What’s the problem?

AI threatens the sustainability of the broader information ecosystem.

EU knowledge institutions that maintain public-interest information resources face loss of visibility and rising costs associated with AI-related activity, while receiving little or no compensation from the commercial deployment of AI systems.

What’s the fix?